Our top pick
- What makes it special
- a 7.9 x 4.7 inch leather journal with 140 refillable pages, a phone slot, and a card slot
Gifts for your girlfriend, under $25
For the girlfriend who deserves a gift chosen on purpose. Seven Valentine's gifts, each chosen because it belongs in her hands, and each with a plain reason she'll feel it was picked for her.
These are Amazon links. If you buy through one, I earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Nobody pays to appear here and commission rates are not an input to how these are ranked.
Chosen from gifts shoppers rated 4.3 out of 5 or better when we found them. Prices as of Nov 2, 2026. Prices and availability may change.
clicked craft
The Night We Met Map Plaque - Custom Map Sign - Where We Met Gifts - First Date Plaque - Personalized Gifts For Girlfriend I Love You Gifts
- What makes it special
- a custom acrylic map plaque UV-printed with your chosen location and available in a range of sizes
$8.90
See it on Amazon →
POPWOW
POPWOW Record Player Birthday Pop Up Card, Vinyl 3D Greeting Card with You're My Favorite Song Message, Music Lover Gift for Wife, Husband, Girlfriend, Boyfriend, 5x7, Includes Envelope and Message Note
- What makes it special
- a 5x7 pop-up card that opens into a 3d record player scene with an envelope and message note included
See it in someone's hands
$9.99
See it on Amazon →
SAPGIF
Couples Gifts for Boyfriend Girlfriend Stocking Stuffers for Women Men | 40 Scratch Off Date Ideas Valentines Day Wedding Bridal Shower Gifts for Him Her Christmas Anniversary Engagement Couple Game
- What makes it special
- 40 scratch-off date cards with a flip coin included, each noting the time, length, and cost of the activity
$6.29was $7.99 — Save 21%
Three more worth a look
Ranked below the four above, still chosen for the same person.
WOKAI
Personalized Bygone Mark Bookmark with Pen Holder,Engraving Leather Magnetic Bookmarks Vintage 26 Letters Name Initials Text Book Marker Clips Gifts for Reading Book Lovers Women (Red, T)
- What makes it special
- a leather magnetic bookmark with a pen holder, engraved with her initial
See it in someone's hands
$9.99
See it on Amazon →
Frabaca
Gifts for Him Her Boyfriend Girlfriend - Crochet Flower with I Love You - Engagement, Anniversary , Wedding,Love ,Birthday Gift for Wife, Husband, Couple,Fiancee - Stuffers for Valentine Christmas
- What makes it special
- hand-knitted from soft yarn into a smiling pot, standing about 4 inches tall on any desk or shelf
$14.99
See it on Amazon →
Pavilion Gift Company
Pavilion Gift Company - Love You Honey - 17oz Organic Shaped Teal Dipped Stamped Letter Novelty Coffee Mug Tea Cup Wife Girlfriend Boyfriend Husband Anniversary Valentine's Day Neutral Modern Present
- What makes it special
- 17 oz stoneware mug with a hand-dipped colored bottom, dishwasher and microwave safe
$16.97
See it on Amazon →Not quite right?